Italian Sizzle Shack — Guests’ Choice Italian Restaurant in Sherrill, NY

Name: Italian Sizzle Shack
Address: 190 E State St, Sherrill, NY 13461

4.5★ across 119 Google reviews · 2026 DineWorthy award

Verification copy

Put it on the wall — order the plaque Download seal + playbook (PDF) Run a new check

The plaque and the framed certificate above are made to order with this exact award. Free US shipping.

DineWorthy awards are earned from public Google reviews against one published standard. The seal may be displayed on the holder's website, window and materials for the awarded year. The printed, framed certificate is issued with the plaque + certificate set.

The holder

Italian Sizzle Shack

190 E State St, Sherrill, NY 13461

Change the award wording Visit website Read all 119 reviews on Google View on the map Suggest an edit

This page links out to toasttab.com as a followed link — part of the award, free, and not conditional on buying anything.

Awarded as Italian Restaurant in Sherrill, NY. Wrong trade? Change the wording yourself — it updates instantly.

Other top-rated businesses near Sherrill, NY

Sweet Life of a Baker Bakery · Sherrill, NY · 4.9★
The Coffee Tree Coffee Shop · Sherrill, NY · 4.6★
Sapori By Antonio Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian Restaurant · Cicero, NY · 4.6★
Crazy Pizza Soho Italian Restaurant · New York, NY · 4.5★
Ferrari's Ristorante Italian Restaurant · Schenectady, NY · 4.6★
Pavin 86 Italian Restaurant · New York, NY · 4.9★
Song' E Napule Italian Restaurant · New York, NY · 4.7★
Joey's Italian Restaurant Italian Restaurant · Syracuse, NY · 4.5★

More: Italian Restaurants in Sherrill, NY · every verified business in Sherrill, NY · Italian Restaurants nationwide