DineWorthy

Browse › Ice Cream Shops

Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shops

25 ice cream shops in 21 cities cleared the DineWorthy standard — a 4.3★ or better rating across 50 or more public Google reviews.

By city

Jacksonville, FL 3Dallas, TX 2Fort Worth, TX 2Albuquerque, NM 1Bean Station, TN 1Caledonia, MO 1El Paso, TX 1Fairmount, GA 1Fort Myers, FL 1Huntington Beach, CA 1Juno Beach, FL 1Morongo Valley, CA 1Naperville, IL 1Orlando, FL 1Philadelphia, PA 1Phoenix, AZ 1Rock Hill, SC 1San Diego, CA 1Sparks, NV 1Vienna, WV 1Warren, OH 1

Most reviewed

Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Dallas, TX
Mr. Sugar Rush
4.9★ · 2,403 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Caledonia, MO
Old Village Mercantile
4.8★ · 1,043 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — San Diego, CA
Cali Cream Homemade Ice Cream
4.7★ · 988 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Juno Beach, FL
Matty's Gelato Factory
4.9★ · 651 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — El Paso, TX
Olly's Italian Ice
4.9★ · 543 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Fairmount, GA
Southern Creamery Co.
4.8★ · 460 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Morongo Valley, CA
The Coyote Cone
4.8★ · 428 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Rock Hill, SC
Bajo Cero San Marcos
4.9★ · 425 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Huntington Beach, CA
Hula Girls Shave Ice
4.8★ · 378 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Warren, OH
Katie's Korner Homemade Ice Cream
4.6★ · 357 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Jacksonville, FL
Mixter Nitrogen Creamery + Coffee Jacksonville
4.9★ · 342 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Orlando, FL
Ice Screamin Orlando
5★ · 336 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Sparks, NV
Paleteria Del Angel
4.9★ · 269 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Fort Worth, TX
La’Creamian®
5★ · 255 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Philadelphia, PA
Chucks Water Ice
4.7★ · 232 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Dallas, TX
So Icy
4.7★ · 217 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Jacksonville, FL
Screaming Cat Ice Cream & Coffee
4.8★ · 211 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Naperville, IL
Dumont Creamery & Cafe - Naperville
4.5★ · 198 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Fort Worth, TX
The Rendon Creamery
4.9★ · 192 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Fort Myers, FL
Belgian Yummies
4.7★ · 189 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Vienna, WV
Mountain State Creamery
4.8★ · 147 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Jacksonville, FL
Ben & Jerry’s
4.7★ · 130 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Phoenix, AZ
Sweet Crimes Candy Vault
4.7★ · 83 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Bean Station, TN
Aunt B's Ice Cream
4.9★ · 83 verified reviews
Verify →
Guests’ Choice Ice Cream Shop — Albuquerque, NM
La Estrella Michoacana
4.7★ · 57 verified reviews
Verify →
Every business on this page cleared one published standard — 4.3★ across 50 or more public Google reviews — read from the public record. No business can pay to appear here.

Check your own business free →